Greens comfortably retain the seat of Melbourne as voter dial barely budges

Greens comfortably retain the seat of Melbourne as voter dial barely budges
David Schout

The Greens’ Ellen Sandell has been re-elected as the Member for Melbourne, securing a third term at the November 26 Victorian Election.  

Ms Sandell is set to pass more than a decade in office this term, after comfortably retaining the seat she first won in 2014, this time against Labor challenger Rebecca Thistleton.

When counting concludes at some stage in December, Melbourne was set to move from a “marginal” to “safe” Greens seat. It was an election where the voter dial barely budged in terms of first preference votes across the electorate, where locals attended 13 different voting centres.

Despite the city undergoing considerable change since the last election in 2018 and facing particularly tough periods as a result of COVID-19, voters largely stuck to their guns from four years ago.

At the time of publication when more than 80 per cent of votes had been counted, the Greens’ primary (or “number one”) vote dropped slightly, from 38.9 per cent to 37.3 per cent.

Labor suffered somewhat of a hit, dropping from 35.9 per cent first-preference votes in 2018 to 30.6 per cent, while the Liberal Party vote remained largely the same, with candidate George Palackalody receiving 17.7 per cent of the overall vote (up slightly from 17.1 per cent).

Colleen Bolger from the Victorian Socialists, which did not field a candidate in 2018, received the fourth-most first preference votes, at 5.5 per cent. These figures, of course, could shift slightly when all early, postal and absentee votes are counted for Melbourne. 

Around 45 per cent of enrolled voters in Melbourne did not cast a vote on November 26, reflecting the wider shift to early voting.

Ms Sandell told North West City News she was “grateful” to serve another term in Melbourne. 


“I’m heartened that the people of Melbourne have elected me with such a positive margin,” she said.


“I hope it’s a sign that our hard work standing up for our local community and their values is recognised, but it’s not something I’ll ever take for granted. I’m ready to keep doing the hard work to make a positive difference.”

The Victorian Greens deputy leader said while she would continue to work on wider issues such as climate change, housing affordability and parliamentary integrity, there were a number of local issues she was looking to address.

“We also desperately need an upgrade to South Kensington Station. We need the government to fund the second stage of the Kensington Primary School master plan, and our public housing residents are still facing many issues the government is refusing to address, such as huge maintenance backlogs in their buildings (and a lack of new public housing),” she said.

“These are all things I’ll be fighting for, among others. If anyone wants to raise any local issue with me they shouldn’t hesitate to let me know at [email protected].

Ms Thistleton, a Kensington resident and former journalist who, like Ms Sandell, is a mother of young children, sent her congratulations to the now three-term Melbourne MP.

“Wrapt and relieved that hope, positivity and action won over hate,” the 37-year-old said on Twitter.

“I’ve loved campaigning, our little team put in a mighty couple of months. Well done and all the best to @ellensandell who has held Melbourne — hope you enjoyed spending today with your kidlets as much as I have.”

Ms Sandell responded: “Thank you Rebecca, and well done to you and your hard-working team. It was a pleasure to campaign alongside other strong women! Thanks for putting up your hand, it takes courage, but our democracy relies on people being willing to do it, and democracy is a precious thing!”

While it was a resounding victory for the Victorian Greens in Melbourne, the statewide result was not quite as strong as was being pushed by those within the party.

On the ABC’s election coverage, Ms Sandell referenced a “green wave moving out across the city”, while leader Samantha Ratnam declared the result a “Greenslide”.


But in raw terms, the party improved its primary vote across the state by just 0.2 per cent (at the time of publishing, when almost 70 per cent of state-wide votes had been counted), while gaining just one lower house seat (the Greens retained Melbourne, Prahran and Brunswick, and gained Richmond).


Earlier in the night the party was optimistic about landing one or several of nearby Albert Park, Footscray, Pascoe Vale and Preston, but all four were retained by Labor.

It reserved strong hopes for Northcote, too, but fell agonisingly short — by just 184 votes, or 0.22 per cent — in that seat, which Labor also retained.

However, Ms Sandell said the overall Greens performance could only be seen as positive. 

“This is the Greens best result ever at a state election. We are on track to double the number of Greens MPs in the Victorian Parliament and hold balance of power in a progressive Upper House. But this isn’t about us – it’s actually about the local people we are elected to represent and their values,” Ms Sandell said. 

“The strong Greens vote means that people care deeply about the issues we were talking about.” •


Caption: Ellen Sandell. 

Image: Julian Meehan.

The changing nature of our spring fair

The changing nature of our spring fair

November 15th, 2023 - Felicity Jack
Stinging nettle

Stinging nettle

November 15th, 2023 - Jacqui van Heerden
Like us on Facebook